Best Buy Co., Inc. (BBY) Is Not a Buy Without a Buyout, But This Stock Is

Page 2 of 2
Even with the recent struggles of Best Buy and Radioshack, Aaron’s remains way cheaper:

Price to Cash Flow
  • Best Buy 8.9 times
  • GameStop -17
  • RadioShack 16.7
  • Aaron’s
    3.1
Not to mention, Aaron’s offers growth at a reasonable price, with a PEG of 1.0, well below its peers:

Price to Earnings to Growth
  • Best Buy 3.4 times
  • GameStop -2.7
  • RadioShack n/a
  • Aaron’s 1.0
Aaron’s is also one of the industry leaders when it comes to returns and profitability…

Return on Equity
  • Best Buy -7%
  • GameStop -13%
  • RadioShack -9%
  • Aaron’s 16%

Operating Margin (TTM)
  • Best Buy 3%
  • GameStop 7%
  • RadioShack n/a
  • Aaron’s 11.5%

I am disappointed Schulze couldn’t put together the funds to pull off a buyout and still fear that Best Buy could end up like a bankrupt and non-existent Circuit City. Best Buy Co., Inc. (NYSE:BBY) has also suspended its future share buybacks and is refraining from providing earnings projections for fiscal 2013. Wall Street expects 2014 Best Buy EPS (ending Jan.) to come in down 20% year-over-year, while the average price target on the company is only $16.70, 12% below where the stock is trading (see how hedge funds are trading Best Buy).

While I’m not interested in investing in electronics retail leader, Best Buy Co., Inc. (NYSE:BBY), there is another “off the radar” (see all Aaron’s hedge fund owners) stock that could be a solid investment. Aaron’s is cheaper than the other notable retailers on a valuation basis and has better return prospects. The company also pays a very modest 0.24% dividend, yet, what’s interesting is that the current dividend payout is only 3.5% of earnings or $7 million, versus the $129 million of cash on hand. If the company did decide to move its payout to 50% of earnings, the dividend yield would be upwards of 4%.

The article Best Buy Is Not a Buy Without a Buyout, But This Stock Is originally appeared on Fool.com.

Copyright © 1995 – 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Page 2 of 2