AutoNation, Inc. (NYSE:AN) Q2 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

AutoNation, Inc. (NYSE:AN) Q2 2023 Earnings Call Transcript July 21, 2023

AutoNation, Inc. beats earnings expectations. Reported EPS is $6.29, expectations were $5.91.

Operator: Good morning. My name is Ellen, and I’ll be your conference operator for today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the AutoNation Second Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] I would now like to turn the call over to Derek Fiebig, Vice President of Investor Relations. You may begin your conference.

Derek Fiebig: Thank you, Ellen, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to AutoNation’s Second Quarter 2023 Conference Call. Leading our call today will be Mike Manley, our CEO; and Joe Lower, our CFO. Following their remarks, we’ll open up the call for questions. . Before we begin, I’d like to remind you that certain statements and information on this call, including any statements regarding our anticipated financial results and objectives, constitute forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Federal Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks that may cause our actual results or performance to differ materially from such forward-looking statements.

Additional discussions of factors that could cause our actual results to differ materially are contained in our press release issued today and in our filings with the SEC. Certain non-GAAP financial measures as defined under SEC rules will be discussed on this call. Reconciliations are provided in our materials and on our website located at investors.autonation.com. With that, I’ll turn the call over to Mike.

Mike Manley: Yes. Thanks, Derek, and good morning, everyone. Thanks for joining us today. As normal, Joe is going to take you through the results in much more detail than I will, but what I’d like to do is talk about the business, give you a perspective from my side, touch on what we see as industry dynamics and then give another update on where we’re heading and the channels that we’re putting in place for growth for the business. So as we know, there obviously continues to be mixed economic signals in the overall economy. But from our point of view, the supply and demand equation, even though it is moderating, we think, has remained favorable for the business. And last quarter, I said that we thought the consumer in no way tapped out, and we still feel that’s the case for sure.

Now notwithstanding the fact that higher interest rates are impacting affordability, lower unit sales over the past few years have contributed to pent-up demand, which, as we see inventory levels improve and some mitigation on that transaction price continue to convert to sales in the marketplace. And the aging vehicle part, which is now about 12.5 years as well as positive household formation, I think, are additional favorable dynamics for the business. And these factors, I think, will continue to be a benefit for new and used vehicle sales going forward. Now as in the first quarter, 2Q light industry vehicle sales increased from a year ago, both driven in this instance by an increase in fleet, but also a notable rise in retail units, which increased by about 10%.

And even with these increases, light vehicle sale remains below what most of us who’ve been in the business a long time would consider trend. Where industry incentives and lease penetration, even though they both have been increasing as late, they’re still significantly below pre-pandemic levels, which I think just to give you an indication, OEMs still have a lot of additional tools to help spur demand if it’s needed in the marketplace. I’m talking about incentives. As you know, Q2 incentives are around $1,700, which was up $700 year-over-year but well below the $4,000 pre-pandemic high and leasing continues to recover, but still only reached about 20% of volume versus 30% pre-pandemic. And I think this channel will further grow, particularly with EVs. And as we close out the year, I think we’ll see that come through.

Now for the second quarter, our new vehicle sales were in line with the overall growth in retail units for the brands we represent. And gross PVRs as expected, continue to mitigate, yet remains robust, I think, at around $4,600 for the quarter. Now clearly, front-end margins have been more resilient than most of us were expecting heading into the year. Now I expect margins will continue to moderate partly to maintain current demand in this higher monthly payment environment and partly as inventory levels continue to increase and fewer vehicles are being sold at MSRP. However, I do not expect margins to return to pre-pandemic levels for the foreseeable future based on higher average selling prices of vehicles and continued lower industry inventory levels.

So let me just move to used vehicles. And remaining consistent with the discussions we’ve had in this area, our focus on enhancing economics through effective outsourcing, efficiency conditioning and agile market pricing, I think, has helped us in the quarter in what has been a bit of a choppy market. On our Q1 call, I discussed how the lower new unit sales over the past years led to a scarcity of supply of late model used vehicles, and this continues, obviously. But in addition, the velocity of sales is also lower than normal as fewer vehicles were sold to fleet and daily rental over the past few years, and consumers are clearly holding on to their vehicles for longer. Now our focus on AutoNation has been on internal sourcing asset turnover and avoiding purchasing vehicles, which require substantial reconditioning to get them up to the AutoNation’s quality standards.

But as we look back on our first quarter results, we recognized that our lower level of used inventory whilst bringing a number of benefits such as depreciation, lower depreciation and funding benefits, we felt was probably constraining volumes more than it should. So we spent a lot of effort in the second quarter, really redoubling our sourcing efforts, particularly in those categories that we think deliver quality inventory so that we could progressively through the quarter, regrow our inventory to get us ready for the third quarter and beyond. And we did that, I think, in a very disciplined, deliberate way and that means we exited the second quarter and now go into the third quarter with increased availability, which we expect will enable us to drive value added unit sales.

And Joe will touch on that. But obviously, that work came with an investment, particularly around the development of those channels that we thought were the best places for us to increase our used inventory. But as I said, Joe will touch on that a bit more. Now the expansion of our AutoNation USA footprint obviously remains a core tenet of our growth and densification efforts. I think densification is important words, and we added our 16th store in Colorado Springs during the quarter. Now as you know, we’ve been intensely focused on expanding the range of products and services we offer and sell to our customers. Now this focus for us is twofold. The first is to increase AutoNation’s share of our customer spend on transportation and mobility.

And the second is to continually develop and grow revenue from what we term as higher recurring revenue sources. Now one key component of this approach is obviously our financial services performance, and I have been very encouraged with the continued performance the teams have delivered. So I know a lot of our guys and girls are on the call, listen to this, thank you for that. That’s your shoutout but please keep that going up because our CFS PVRs structurally higher despite many expecting this valuable source of margin to come under significant pressure, particularly given prevailing interest rates. And I think it’s because our team have always taken a balanced approach, driving both finance penetration levels, but really importantly, increasing per-unit product sales.

And as such, we’ve increased our per unit performance. And as a result, the team delivered a record PVR of more than $2,000 almost [ph] for the quarter. Now talking to higher recurring revenue streams. Let me touch on After-Sales. As you know, we’ve constantly talked about this, and we’ve been very deliberate and consistently growing this high-margin, higher-frequency business, and we recorded a gross profit record of more than $540 million, which is up 13% from a year ago. Now notwithstanding the decrease in late-model vehicle part, which, as you know, is where all franchise dealerships have the higher penetration and obviously, lower new unit sales over the past year, I think that we have successfully been able to combat our headwinds, still work in progress, but a good result in the quarter, no doubt.

And a big part of that is our focus on expanding our technician workforce and serving more customers. So I’m expecting to be able to talk about further growth in the future on these calls. Now business continues to generate significant cash flow, which when you combine it with the strength of our balance sheet allows us to continue to invest to change our business for the long term, obviously make investments in our core operations but also return capital to our shareholders, and we do that through share repurchases. And during the second quarter, we invested more than $200 million to repurchase over 1.5 million shares at a price of about $132 per share. And year-to-date, we’ve reduced our shares outstanding by more than 8%. Now as we previously said, the structural changes we have made to AutoNation during the time when the supply and demand economics have been a tailwind for our operations, we’ll have a lasting and meaningful impact on a go-forward basis and help to continue to drive shareholder value and returns.

So before I hand the call over to Joe, let me provide some updates on where we’re heading and talk a little bit more about this channel for growth. As I’ve previously discussed, we’ve been very intentional, I think, on looking at areas where we can expand and grow to meet the transportation needs of our 11 million-plus customers in their households. And there is a very significant opportunity set of customers who really only transact with AutoNation once or twice or have become active over the years. And we are commencing a much more targeted effort to engage with this customer base. So I think it’s an asset that we don’t talk enough about, certainly externally, but very focused on internally. When you had a business that over many years has not only built up some phenomenal franchise assets in great locations with what I think is great density in our operations, those 11 million plus households and customers that we’ve interacted with represent increasingly with technology and a very, very valuable source for the company.

And Rich Lennox, our CMO, who joined us from Macy’s, as you know, brings substantial nonautomotive retail experience, so he is already looking at both lifetime value and customer loyalty with his team, and I’m really excited about what I expect to come from that area. Because if we can extend our core business and increase the depth and breadth of our product and services offer, that will deepen and lengthen our relationship with our customers as well as continuing to provide a convenient, trusted and transparent customer experience, which I think is vital to be successful in the marketplace. And it would put a lot of time and effort, obviously, as an organization, as a group of people and those customer-centric actions, and I’m very pleased to see that it hasn’t been lost on some industry observers.

And in this May, 143 of our stores were certified as 2023 Dealers of Excellence by J.D. Power. So shout-out to those stores, well done guys. And that recognizes dealers for exceptional customer service. Now 143 stores this year, that’s up from 129 last year and 78 in 2021. So great progress. I’m also very pleased with the performance of AN Finance as the group continues to expand. As Joe has often said, we’re taking a metered approach and pace to make sure that we can progressively increase the penetration of this business with the vehicles sold to AN USA stores and they are doing that, and they’re also navigating, as you can imagine, quite an interesting and sometimes challenging environment with all of the rate rises. RepairSmith, I think, has extended the reach of the brand of our aftersales business, and we’ve begun to integrate this mobile service and repair business into AutoNation ecosystem.

And one of the things that I think will become increasingly obvious is as we continue to grow AN USA, it’s the only stand-alone used car dedicated business that had one of the most convenient service and warranty provision in the entire marketplace. Imagine that phenomenal selection of used vehicles, great transparent pricing, great preparation, good quality vehicles, but then you also get the best convenience to have your vehicle serviced and repaired by mobile, well-qualified technician. So really pleased about how that business is coming together. A lot of work to do, obviously, but I think it’s going to be a complement to the other things that we’re doing. I’m talking about used car business. It’s obviously grown substantially from our pre-pandemic levels, both our franchise stores and through AN USA, now 16 locations with the addition of Colorado Springs, increases our footprint density in that area, which is another important strategy that we’re focused on to drive market efficiency and economics.

Now over time, we expect our actions and initiatives will garner a larger share of wallet from consumers which will reduce our relative exposure to the more cyclical parts of the business. And that approach is really centered on to that customer base I mentioned and talked a little bit about earlier and the 11 million households that we serve. Now during the second quarter, we built on more customers than Q1 have now added, more than 400,000 new customers for the year. And we’re focused on enhancing our relationship with active customers. But as I mentioned, really going back in, reactivating lapsed customers, adding products and services to our base so that we can really be that comprehensive provider to all of those customers that either are part of our active customer base or hopefully will be reactivated through the work and the products and services that were added.

And we think that these actions will add to the structural changes that we’ve brought to the business over the past few years. Now that said, I have to say, we are very focused on the franchise business and supporting our vehicle manufacturer partners, and we are in a privileged position to have a lot of great relationships with some of the best automotive brands in the world. And I’m pleased to say in June, we added to our franchise density in Southern California with the purchase of Bob Baker Auto Group in Carlsbad. Welcome, everybody. Really pleased to have you on board. Now you guys are going to bring at least $300 million, hopefully more of annual revenue and five great stores and then obviously help us with building our customer base, as I said.

And with that, Joe, I’m going to hand it over to you to take us through the details. Thank you.

Photo by Potters Media on Unsplash

Joe Lower: Thank you, Mike, and good morning, everyone. As Mike described, this quarter’s results were really driven by healthy margins, record aftersales performance, record CFS PVRs, disciplined expense management and our balanced capital deployment strategy, which largely offset used unit sales, lower growth PVRs and higher financing costs. The result was second quarter adjusted EPS of $6.29 per share, just below last year’s record EPS of $6.48 and above the $6.07 we reported in the first quarter of this year. Second quarter total revenue of $6.9 billion was essentially flat from a year ago as increases in new vehicle volume and the continued growth of our aftersales business offset lower used vehicle sales. AutoNation’s new unit sales increased by 8% in the quarter, which, as Mike mentioned, was largely in line with the overall industry when adjusted for brand mix.

This increase in volume partially offset lower new vehicle PVR margins, which, although moderating still remain healthy at $4,600. Inventory for new vehicles increased by one day from the first quarter to 26 days. As is the case with the overall industry, we have a wide dispersion of inventory levels by brand and model. In core brands are generally below the company average, domestic brands generally above and premium luxury generally in line with the average. The overall new vehicle market remained healthy during the quarter as almost 40% of our vehicles were sold at MSRP, which continues to be far higher than pre-pandemic levels. This is down from about 45% in Q1. Our total used vehicle gross profit decreased by 14% from a year ago, reflecting lower unit sales and used PVR margins which declined slightly from a year ago.

We continue to support our used vehicle economics to effective self-sourcing, which was above 90% during the quarter. After-Sales gross profit grew 13% year-over-year as we continue to drive strong performance in this key area of our business: customer pay, warranty, internal and collision all experienced double-digit growth year-over-year. The recurring revenue stream from After-Sales continues to grow with our trailing 12-month gross profit of nearly $400 million or more than 24% since 2019. The performance also remained very strong, and we continue to lead the sector with PVRs exceeding $2,800 for the quarter. We are pleased that our product penetration of more than two contracts per vehicle pushed the percentage of CFS profit from products above 70% and outpaced lower profits associated with the finance portion of our service offerings.

Customers continue to invest in products which will protect both the performance and appearance of their vehicles. As Mike mentioned, we’re very pleased with the performance of AutoNation Finance, and the progress we have made integrating the business into our operations. We will continue to grow this business in a measured manner supporting our AutoNation stores. AutoNation Finance represented over 20% of new loans originated at our AutoNation USA stores in the month of June, which is facilitating our shift to a higher tier credit customer. Moving to costs; SG&A as a percentage of gross was 61.9% for the quarter, remaining significantly below pre-pandemic levels and reflecting permanent structural changes to our cost basis. SG&A as a percentage of gross profit was slightly higher than recent periods, reflecting investments in technology and new business initiatives as we expand our offerings to customers as well as additional advertising support for our [indiscernible] program, as Mike referenced earlier.

As noted in today’s press release, we excluded $12.4 million of after-tax expense from our second quarter results. These expenses are related to weather events, including major hailstorms in the quarter that damaged more than 2,800 vehicles. In comparison, there were no such weather-related losses last quarter or in the year ago quarterly period. Second quarter floorplan interest expense was $33 million, impacted by both higher rates and increased inventory levels. This all culminated in adjusted net income for the second quarter of $285 million or $6.29 per share. As Mike referenced, our cash generation remains robust and combined with the strength of our balance sheet provides us significant capacity to deploy capital into our businesses and return capital to our shareholders.

Our cash flow from operations, incorporating proceeds from additional floor plan was almost $240 million in the quarter, and that included cash tax payments of $190 million. During the quarter, we invested more than $180 million in our business operations, including the acquisitions of five new dealerships, as Mike mentioned, and over $100 million of a capital expenditure. We also continue to expand our AutoNation USA footprint with our third new location this year, which increases our offerings in a key strategic market. The AutoNation USA stores play an integral part in both our long-term growth plans and the achievement of scale, scope and density in our markets to better serve our customers. We also continue to return capital to AutoNation shareholders through share repurchase.

Year-to-date, we have now repurchased four million shares or 8% of the shares outstanding at the beginning of the year. The pace of share repurchase is down slightly from previous two years but still very significant by any comparable measure. We currently have approximately $670 million of remaining authority for share repurchase. We ended the second quarter with total liquidity of approximately $1.4 billion, our covenant leverage of debt-to-EBITDA was slightly below two times or at the bottom of our historical two times to three times range. And earlier this month, we successfully amended and extended our credit facility. The new five-year facility has similar pricing to the prior facility, while increasing our revolving borrowing capacity by $100 million to $1.9 billion and increasing the flexibility of our financial covenants.

Looking ahead, we will continue to focus on operational excellence and disciplined capital allocation supporting growth to drive long-term shareholder value. With that, I will turn it back over to Mike.

Mike Manley: Yes. Thanks, Joe. So before just taking your questions, obviously, what I want to do is to thank the people that every single day deliver results for us, and that’s our 24,000 associates. Thank you for what you’ve done in the quarter. Also, as you know, in May, we announced that Joe will be moving to a newly created role, which is basically going to oversee all of the business transformation initiatives for the company. Joe will continue to report directly to me and he’s going to coordinate the execution and integration of our business transformation products really with a focus on process improvement, operational efficiency. And I think as a result of that will help accelerate our growth. Now I can tell you that since I joined the organization in late ’21, Joe, in a very short space of time has been a trusted and advising me in business [ph] as I am incredibly pleased and excited as he moves into this new role to be continue to work with him.

And I think he’s done a tremendous job in the management of our balance sheet and guiding our capital deployment. But you also need to look below that and really look at what the business and how the business was performing in terms of some of the efficiencies, some of the cost base and everything else. And you can see the lasting effect that him and his team, in conjunction with the operational people, have added to our business, and I think it’s absolutely tremendous. Now in August, Tom Szlosek will join us and replace Joe. And many of you know Tom, he’s helped drive change in innovation across medical technology and manufacturing industries and frankly, like Joe, the best-in-class Fortune 500 CFO. And Tom is going to be responsible for continuing our focus on operational excellence, obviously, the development of our company as well as making sure we continue with a really balanced but focused capital allocation approach.

So just a quick update on those things. And with that, should we open up to questions?

Derek Fiebig: Yes. Yes. Ellen, if you could please remind people how to get in queue.

See also 10 Best Gold Stocks Under $50 and 25 Best Places to Live with Arthritis and Fibromyalgia.

Q&A Session

Operator: [Operator Instructions] The first question comes from John Murphy from Bank of America. John, your line is now open. Please go ahead.

John Murphy: Good morning, everybody. Joe, congrats on the new role, and I’ll start with that. Mike and Joe, as you look at this, there’s incremental dollars being spent here. Just curious if you could talk about what those were in the quarter for these initiatives, but also maybe more broadly, I mean you got 11 million customers in your Rolodex there, as we would say in the olden days that you can really leverage and potentially engage with for a longer period of time. As you’re going through this exercise of transformation, what does that mean? I mean — and could it mean that you’re holding on to these customers in that vehicle for 10 years as opposed to five years and the profit opportunity is 2x or maybe more. I mean how are you kind of thinking about this holistically as the sort of the addressable market of what you could hit after?

And is it more traditional things like another used vehicle sale and extended parts and service and then CIG and doing some more financing? Or are there other things that are potentially entering the equation as you look at the opportunity set?

Mike Manley: So John, I’m going to start with that and then Joe can talk about the investments that we’ve made. So when you look at our customer base that we have built up, there are a number of things that I think are really relevant. Firstly, the percentage of active customers within there, and we can define an active customer by somebody that has a transaction within a period of time. So if you took active customers, including service, the actual percentage of active customers in the 11 million is well below 50%, well below 50%. So then you have to ask yourself, why do you get that level of attrition with the rest to the customers? Because if you look at our reputation scores and our customer satisfaction scores, it’s purely not because of that.

And it’s because circumstances and needs change within that customer base. And that may well be the geographic position to our dealerships has changed. They’re further away or as the vehicles age they’ve decided to take a nonfranchise solution to service and repairs or a whole host of different reasons. And as we’ve been — as we’ve looked at that and spent time working with that customer base, identifying what is driving that, we’re adding and building our business so that we can offer products and services that meet their changing needs from when they maybe originally bought the vehicle, more convenience in terms of service and repair so that, for example, if they are 20 miles, 25 miles away from a dealership and just looking for a quick oil change, we can provide that at a great level of convenience for them as well as well as then build out different products.

We’ve added the finance company that was really twofold. One, because it’s a deep relationship with customers, obviously. And secondly, it was a perfect match for the growth that we were trying to achieve and are achieving with AN USA. So without taking too much of the call, I think in the question itself, you answered a lot of it. And that is a big percentage of those customers are one and done. And there’s an opportunity for us there. A big percentage of those customers have needs outside of themselves in their household, whether it is family members or whether it is relative. And what we are striving to do through the expansion of our products and services is increase the average length of the relationship that we have. And of all of the spend they make on transportation and mobility, however, you want to define it and I’m not too interested in what word you used, that we want more of that and earn more of that because of the quality of service, the price of our service and the transparency working with AutoNation.