Are These The Big Dividend Gainers Of 2014?

As I regularly scan Wall Street research, I sometimes come across an eye-catching headline.

Merrill Lynch’s recent report on agricultural equipment provider AGCO Corporation (NYSE:AGCO) is a great example: “Margin Upside, Divy Could Soar, Raising Estimates.” It’s the middle part that got my attention.

Merrill’s analysts noted the dividend could be poised for a big change: “AGCO currently pays out only 7% of earnings per share (EPS) in the form of dividends. The dividend could triple in the next few years on flat EPS of $6 if the company simply goes to a 20% payout ratio.”

What those analysts didn’t say: Many companies pay out 40% or more of their income to dividends, which means the dividend payments could actually swell far higher than these analysts suspect.

The Revolution Is Already Underway
Have the executives at Agco been under a rock these past few years as other companies have already sharply hiked their payouts? No, they just wanted to show an extra dose of patience before making such a big move. After all, it feels as if we’re not far removed from many recent global crises.

Yet Agco, like many other firms, now sees that the U.S. and Europe, which still account for half of global GDP, are proving to have increasingly resilient economies. And you can see the confidence in the form of improving financial projections: In its view of Agco, for example, Merrill Lynch foresees “further opportunity for margin expansion in coming years based on the company’s numerous internal initiatives,” predicting free cash flow will rise nearly 150%, to $570 million, by 2015.

Not Yet On The Radar
As Agco’s dividend currently yields just 0.6%, most income-focused investors still haven’t looked at this company. A tripling of the dividend would simply push the yield into respectable (but not great) territory. But what about companies that have decent yields now, but are poised for great yields in the years to come?

I went in search of stocks that currently yield more than 1%, but could be yielding 3%, 4% or even 5% in a few years. To find them, I focused on companies with very low payout ratios. Of all the companies in the S&P 500, 400 (mid-cap) and 600 (small cap), these are the companies with the lowest payout ratios with a current dividend yield of at least 1%.

Source: ThomsonReuters

In line with Merrill Lynch’s logic regarding Agco, these companies could triple their payout ratio, pushing up their dividend yields above 4% in some instances.

Of course, investors may want to seek out companies that already offer more appealing yields but are in a position to boost their dividends at a still-strong pace. Looking at that same group of 1,500 companies, here are the highest current yielders that have a payout ratio below 30%.

Source: ThomsonReuters

You’ll notice that women’s apparel retailer Cato Corp (NYSE:CATO) makes both lists. The company is what we here at StreetAuthority call a “Hidden High-Yielder.” Go to any popular financial website, and it will appear as if Cato pays annual dividend of a paltry $0.20 a share. But looks are deceiving. Cato likes to maintain a conservative formal dividend, but often manages to slip in irregular dividend payments that can start to really add up.