AG Mortgage Investment Trust, Inc. (NYSE:MITT) Q3 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

AG Mortgage Investment Trust, Inc. (NYSE:MITT) Q3 2023 Earnings Call Transcript November 7, 2023

Operator: Good day and thank you for standing by. Welcome to the AG Mortgage Trust Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. At this time all participants are in a listen-only mode. After management remarks there will be a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Please be advised that today’s conference is being recorded. [Operator Instructions] I’d now like to turn the call over to Jenny Neslin, General Counsel for the company. Please go ahead.

Jenny Neslin: Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to the third quarter 2023 Earnings Call for AG Mortgage Investment Trust. With me on the call today are T.J. Durkin, our CEO and President; Nick Smith, our Chief Investment Officer; and Anthony Rossiello, our Chief Financial Officer. Before we begin, please note that the information discussed in today’s call may contain forward-looking statements. Any forward-looking statements made during today’s call are subject to risks, certain risks and uncertainties, which are outlined in our SEC filings, including under the headings Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements, Risk Factors and Management’s Discussion and Analysis. The company’s actual results may differ materially from these statements.

We encourage you to read the disclosure regarding forward-looking statements contained in our SEC filings including our most recently filed Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022, our quarterly report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2023, and our subsequent reports filed from time to time with the SEC. Except as required by law, we are not obligated and do not intend to update or to review or revise any forward-looking statements whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise. During the call today, we will refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures. Please refer to our SEC filings for reconciliations to the most comparable GAAP measures. We will also reference the earnings presentation that was posted to our website this morning.

To view the slide presentation, turn to our website, www.agmit.com, and click on the link for the Q3 2023 earnings presentation on the home page. Again, welcome to the call, and thank you for joining us today. With that, I’d like to turn the call over to T.J.

T.J. Durkin: Thank you, Jenny. Good afternoon, everyone. The third quarter continued to be a challenging one for both fixed income and mortgage markets, but I’m extremely happy with how MITT performed in what was a busy quarter for the team. I think the team did a great job of protecting book value again, as we have over the past few quarters, with a modest drop in adjusted book value of just $0.14 from $11.52 per share in June to $11.38, before factoring in onetime transaction-related expenses of $7.6 million, driving adjusted book value to an even $11 per share as of quarter end. During the quarter, MITT generated $0.10 of EAD and paid its $0.18 dividend. We are reporting a $0.33 loss, again, namely driven by one-time transaction expenses as well as the valuation adjustment at Arc Home, which Anthony will walk through in more detail.

As we have discussed in prior calls, our prudent and disciplined securitization strategy is beginning to evidence itself in our earnings power. The EAD improvement quarter-over-quarter reflects a combination of higher NIM off of our investment portfolio and related hedging strategy, as well as improving fundamentals at Arc Home. During the third quarter, we remained disciplined completing 2 securitizations, which lowered our economic leverage to 1.2x from 1.6x and have ample liquidity of almost $119 million to end the quarter. As I stated last quarter, we continue to see an environment with higher ROEs based on some competition retreating and opportunities that we believe are just beginning to present themselves given the lingering effects of the disruption amongst the regional bank balance sheets.

Finally, to adjust the WMC merger, we are happy to report our shareholders vote today was successful in approving the merger. Meanwhile, as you may be aware, WMC adjourned its shareholders’ meeting due to a lack of quorum and is still in process of obtaining the required shareholder approval. The WMC Board continues to unanimously recommend that WMC stockholders approve the transaction, and we will continue to work with them towards successfully completing the merger. The transaction is still expected to close during the fourth quarter. Now as we head into the fourth quarter and 2024, I believe we have taken material actions to help improve the profitability of MITT for the future through the strategic merger with WMC to gain scale efficiencies along with our focus on improving Arc Home’s volumes and profitability through management changes, which we believe is now complete with Arc Home’s recent addition of Brian Devlin as its new incoming President and will become Arc Home’s CEO.

With more than two decades of diverse mortgage industry experience, Brian’s extensive background in product development, capital markets and the non-agency space positions him as the ideal leader to steer Arc Home during its next phase of growth. The Arc Home team is very excited for what lies ahead. I’ll now turn it over to Nick to discuss our investment activities at Arc Home in more detail.

Nick Smith: Thanks, T.J. Before considering transaction expenses associated with the WMC merger and the 2 loan securitizations executed during the quarter, our book value was down approximately 1.2%. Having the benefit of most mortgage REITs reporting already, MITT’s results represent a significant outperformance on a relative basis. While the third quarter presented similar challenges as past quarters, residential credit spreads were resilient relative to their more liquid counterparts, such as Agency RMBS. This combined with its modest economic leverage resulted in comparatively better performance. During the third quarter, we secured nearly $0.75 billion of residential homes across 2 transactions and attractive cost of funds while selling out a significant portion for Agency RMBS exposure.

A businessperson examining financial graphs and charts of the company’s portfolio, while surrounded by residential mortgage loan documents.

Along with this activity, we also sold certain non-agency loans and legacy credit-sensitive loans, generating capital we can deploy in our target asset classes. This activity decreased economic leverage to approximately 1.2x, the lowest in over 2 years after pivoting to our securitization strategy in 2021. In the previous quarter’s prepared remarks, we emphasized that we would appropriately size the aggregation risk based on current and expected market conditions. Although bond market volatility is well off highs of recent quarters, we expect it to remain elevated given the massive buildup in rich countries’ public debts, the unwinding of quantitative easing, along with significant economic uncertainty and geopolitical risk. Given this uncertainty, we continue to manage the balance sheet to modest levels of leverage while remaining focused on credit.

While residential mortgage credit fundamentals and technicals remained resilient, creating a backdrop for this quarter’s relative outperformance, we have not and will not widen our credit box to combat low origination volumes, even as we face 3-to-4 decade lows in existing home sales and housing affordability, along with multi-decade highs in mortgage rates. Instead, we are focused on items we can control. Third quarter funding volumes at Arc Home of approximately $530 million were 225% of the first quarter’s volumes. When normalizing this versus aggregate mortgage originations reported by the MBA, this represents an approximately 67% increase in market share relative to the overall market. These gains have been made largely by taking market share from other wholesale non-agency focused originators, along with significant growth in other channels as large and medium-sized retail originators have adopted non-agency products to offset agency production declines.

Although we expect origination margins to remain compressed, we do expect modest gains in the coming quarters. These gains along with the continued growth puts Arc Home on a path to become profitable in the coming quarters. We acknowledge this is behind schedule, but it’s worth noting that the original projections were estimated based upon more favorable economic backdrop that has been realized. Moving on to our portfolio. Earlier in our prepared remarks, we reiterated our commitment to maintaining prudent underwriting standards even as many competitors have not. We believe that because of its discipline, MITT’s existing exposure continues to significantly outperform the original underwriting. As you can see on Page 9, the delinquency of the aggregate exposure of the securitized and non-securitized portfolio is only approximately 1%.

This strong credit performance, combined with the ample liquidity for reinvestment and attractive yields and obtaining term debt prior to the move to significantly higher rates is the foundation on which the earnings power of the company is built on. I will now turn the call over to Anthony.

Anthony Rossiello: Thank you, Nick. Good afternoon. The notable themes of MITT’s third quarter include stable book value performance, improvement in EAD, an increase in purchase and securitization activity while also transacting strategic sales of certain assets and our continued progress towards closing our merger with WMC. During the third quarter, the company recorded book value of $11.37 per share and adjusted book value of $11 per share. This represents a decrease of 4.5% from prior quarter. However, the decline in book value this quarter was primarily driven by transaction-related expenses. During the quarter, MITT incurred $4.9 million of expenses related to the pending merger with WMC along with $2.7 million of upfront expenses recorded in connection with 2 securitizations.

In aggregate, these transaction expenses accounted for approximately 3.3% of the book value decline. On the income statement side, we recognized a GAAP net loss available to common shareholders of approximately $6.8 million or $0.33 per fully diluted share, which again is largely driven by $7.6 million or $0.38 of transaction-related expenses. When evaluating our performance exclusive of the impact of transaction-related expenses, we experienced continued improvement in earnings available for distribution and mark-to-market losses on our investment portfolio were largely offset by gains on our securitized debt and interest rate swaps. Our book value performance is also reflective of a reduction in the fair value of our investment in Arc Home as we reduced the valuation multiple from 0.94 of book to 0.89 of book.

This reduction resulted in an unrealized mark-to-market loss of $1.9 million to MITT or a decline in book value of approximately 1%. Our investment portfolio increased 5% quarter-over-quarter to $4.7 billion, driven by loan purchases of approximately $700 million. We were also active in the securitization markets this quarter, securitizing approximately $725 million of EAD. In addition, we sold approximately $149 million of Agency RMBS, $74 million of non-agency loans and $69 million of legacy reperforming loans, which returned capital for reinvestment. As a result of these securitizations and asset sales, our financing profile also improved with 87% of our financing funded through securitization at a weighted average cost of 4.7%. Our economic leverage ratio at quarter end was 1.2 turns, of which 0.9 turns related to our credit portfolio and 0.3 to our Agency RMBS portfolio.

In addition, we ended the quarter with approximately $1.9 billion of borrowing capacity to support continued growth in our portfolio. We generated earnings available for distribution or EAD, of $0.10 per share for the third quarter. Net interest income, inclusive of interest earned on our hedge portfolio, was $0.74 per share, which is $0.01 higher from prior quarter. Net interest income exceeded operating expenses and our preferred dividends, generating earnings of $0.17 per share. This was offset by a loss of $0.07 contributed from Arc Home. However, Arc Home’s contribution to EAD improved by $0.02 quarter-over-quarter when excluding the impact of gains recorded by Arc Home’s loans sold to MITT. Lastly, as of September 30, our total liquidity approximated $119 million of cash, and we continue to deploy this capital into our target assets post quarter end.

This concludes our prepared remarks, and we now like to open the call for questions.

See also The 15 Best Selling Products Online and 12 Cheap Global Stocks to Buy.

Q&A Session

Operator: [Operator Instructions] And our first question will come from Trevor Cranston with JMP Securities. Your line is open.

Trevor Cranston: Hey, thanks. Can you guys talk a little bit about the yield and return profile of the loans that you strategically sold during the quarter? And then as a second part of the question, as you’re looking at new investments, can you talk about sort of the supply of loans you’re seeing available and if there’s been any sort of additional supply coming in of banks looking to get ahead of regulatory changes? Thanks.

Nick Smith: Yes, certainly. Thanks, Trevor. This is Nick. On the loans we sold, as Anthony mentioned, some of the loans we sold were credit-sensitive loans from legacy positions where the thesis of the original investment have very much played out. The debt was inefficient in our balance sheet. For the loans that are part of our target asset class, there has been sort of a narrative that others have spoken about as well of there being strong real money bids for these insofar as we can sell assets at levels through where our target equity returns are, we will evaluate that, and oftentimes, execute on that. With regard to your second question, I believe that’s very much an evolving story that Wall Street Journal and others have picked up on as recently as today.

We are seeing additional opportunities there. I think it’s in its early stages, and we’re paying close attention to it. I think some of the folks that have pounded the table say that such an amazing opportunity or maybe a little bit ahead of a bit. But we are expecting that to become more meaningful. And we continue to see ROEs in, call it, mid- to high teens after deploying, call it, a [indiscernible] leverage on our, call it, approximately 0% to 5%, 0% to 10% retained interest.

Trevor Cranston: Got it. Okay. And on the transaction expenses related to the merger, are you expecting any additional expenses to flow through in the fourth quarter, or was that solely a third quarter event?

Anthony Rossiello: Trevor, it’s Anthony. Yes, so the expenses that came through this quarter are the bulk of it. On the mid side, we have about another $1.1 million that we’re expecting to come through in the fourth quarter. And then, obviously, when you think about total transaction expenses, there’s the termination fee which is on the other side of the house.

Operator: Thank you. Our next question will come from Bose George with KBW. Your line is open.

Bose George: Hey, good afternoon. I just got a follow-up to that in terms of deploying new capital. I guess you showed you’ve got $119 million of cash. How should we think about the timeline for deploying that? And how much of a cash cushion do you want to keep?

Nick Smith: On the cash cushion side, we closely monitor reserves based upon our internal risk models. On the cash deployment side, that leaves us probably, call it, 40-ish million to spend where we’re looking today relative to that reserve, but that reserve obviously moves over time relative to the repositioning of assets. So I wouldn’t say that’s a hard number, certainly that can evolve over time as we rotate the portfolio.

Bose George: So just because the $40 million is what’s available to invest or after the cash cushion?

Nick Smith: Yes, versus approximately where we size risk reserves today. That being said, over time, risk reserves can move around and we can rotate the portfolio.

Bose George: Okay. And so if we take that and deploy that to the ROE that you’ve got there, the 17%, and then sort of run your expense ratio through there. I mean do you feel like you guys can get to a double-digit return with the scale? I guess you’ll have some benefit from Western in terms of taking the cost base down. So after all, that’s kind of in the numbers, do you get to a double-digit ROE?