5 States with the Most Expensive Car Insurance in the US

2. New York 

Average Insurance Cost: $1,235

New York is the second most expensive state in the US for car insurance. New York State’s New York City is the most populated and global city in the US. The state is a cultural, financial, and entertainment hub with famous attractions including the Statue of Liberty and Times Square. As of 2021, the estimated average insurance cost for cars in New York is $1,235.