This article takes a look at the 5 Highest Quality Ice Cream Brands in the United States. If you wish to check out our detailed analysis on the ice cream market in US, its key players and other high quality brands, you may go to 20 Highest Quality Ice Cream Brands in the United States.
5. Turkey Hill Dairy:
Butterfat Content: 16.5%
Turkey Hill Dairy is a well-known American company that specializes in crafting a diverse range of cold and frozen treats, including ice creams, frozen yogurt, and iced tea. Located in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, Turkey Hill Dairy takes pride in being the producer of one of the top-selling premium ice cream brands in the nation and a leading name in refrigerated iced tea.
Over the years, Turkey Hill has experienced significant growth, expanding its reach to 49 states and several countries across three continents. With an impressive output, the company produces an average of 29 million gallons of ice cream annually, offering an astonishing selection of 72 distinct flavors.
4. Salt & Straw:
Butterfat Content: 17%
Salt & Straw operates multiple ice cream shops across the country and prioritizes sourcing dairy from grass-fed cows for superior taste. Their menu of unique flavors changes with each season, featuring options like Hunk a Chunk Peanut Butter and Jelly, Honey Lavender, Cinnamon Snickerdoodles, and Buttermilk Pancakes Bacon and Eggs.
Even if you don’t have a nearby location, Salt & Straw provides nationwide delivery for any pint of ice cream you desire. For a regular supply of delicious ice cream, you can join Salt & Straw’s Pints Club, which delivers five different flavors to your doorstep every month.
3. Van Leeuwen’s:
Butterfat Content: 18%
Van Leeuwen’s, established in 2008 in New York City, has a widespread presence with several local scoop shops across the country. If you are unable to visit one of their shops, you can still enjoy their delicious ice cream pints, which are available in the freezer aisles of many grocery stores. Additionally, like other brands mentioned, Van Leeuwen’s offers nationwide shipping for convenient ice cream pint delivery.
What sets Van Leeuwen’s apart from other ice cream brands is their extensive range of unique flavors. From Kraft Macaroni and Cheese to Honeycomb, Royal Wedding Cake, and Earl Grey Tea, they offer flavors that truly stand out. Moreover, they cater to vegans by offering a wide selection of vegan flavors.
2. Graeter’s:
Butterfat Content: 18%
Graeter’s, a Cincinnati-based company established in 1870, has been creating ice cream for generations. They proudly maintain their rich heritage through their French Pot process, hand-packing and producing small batches of ice cream even as technology advances.
Every month, Graeter’s introduces a fresh seasonal flavor, making it almost like a fantastic ice cream calendar. With a variety of flavors to choose from, options like Boldly Bearcat or Buckeye Blitz are excellent starting points. And for movie candy lovers, Midnight Snack offers a delicious combination of malt, chocolate-dipped pretzels, peanut butter cups, and brownies that shouldn’t be missed.
1. McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams:
Butterfat Content: 19%
McConnell’s Fine Ice Creams was established in 1949 in Santa Barbara, California. This family-owned business, now in its third generation, takes great pride in crafting ice creams from scratch. They utilize the highest quality local, sustainable, and organic ingredients sourced from partner farms and suppliers, avoiding the use of preservatives, stabilizers, or additives. The result is ice creams with unadulterated flavor, consistently smooth texture, extraordinary creaminess, and a delightful 70-year history of producing some of the world’s finest ice creams.
McConnell’s offers a range of truly unique flavors, including Honey and Cornbread Cookies, Sprinkle Cake, and Eureka Lemon and Marionberries. Additionally, they cater to different dietary preferences with a selection of dairy-free flavors, such as Salted Caramel Chocolate Swirl.
Insider Monkey focuses on uncovering the best investment ideas of hedge funds and insiders. Please subscribe to our free daily enewsletter to get the latest investment ideas from hedge funds’ investor letters by entering your email address below. You can also take a look at 20 Countries With Best Desserts In The World and 20 Most Popular Desserts in America.
