5 Best Car Insurance Companies Of 2023

2. Nationwide 

Average Rating: 5 stars 

Nationwide, a Fortune 100 company with over 90 years of experience, offers insurance and financial services and stands among the top auto insurance companies. In 2022, despite economic challenges, they showed strong performance, with record sales of $57 billion. They paid nearly $19 billion in claims and benefits amid high inflation and volatile markets. Nationwide maintained S&P AAA capital levels and planned for disciplined growth in financial services, commercial lines, and personal lines in 2023.