3. Kat & Theo
We are continuing our list of romantic anniversary ideas in NYC with Kat & Theo, that is tucked into the Flatiron District and is led by Chef David Fisher, who was a semifinalist in the 2016 San Pellegrino Young Chefs competition. He creates simple and delicious meals, like the popular lamb tongue pastrami with homemade stout mustard. There’s a brick-lined bar where you can get a cocktail or two before dinner. The dining room has a gorgeous stone fireplace. It’s a beautiful romantic spot that would be great for any anniversary.