8. Dutch Kills
At number 8 on our list of best pick up bars in NYC for singles over 40 we have Dutch Kills that is a very common hang out for older people in the Long Island area, making it great for our list of best pick up bars in NYC for singles over 40. The bar opens in the evening, and the party goes on until late into the night. If you happen to live in the vicinity, then you are seriously missing out if you are not going there regularly.