5. J & V Pizzeria
Founded in: 1950
Next on our list of oldest pizza places in New York City is this tiny little place in Brooklyn that has its fair share of popularity. Unfortunately, J & V Pizzeria is often neglected to be mentioned around the web as one of the oldest pizza places in NYC. The reason for this completely escapes me since it invariably receives positive reviews for its taste and ambiance. The prices are reasonable too as it sets the price of a plain slice of pizza at merely $2.75.
