In this article, we will have a look at 10 Best Property & Casualty Insurance Stocks to Buy.
Property and casualty (P&C) insurers face the hardest market mainly because of the increasing expenses, large claims payouts, and price-shopping policyholders. To revive the growth, they are required to shift to a more proactive strategy and exploit new developments and opportunities available in auto, homeowners’, and renters’ insurance.
With several insurers posting sound profitability in 2023, and in response to some notable improvements in the reinsurance market, the insurance market in 2Q 2024 was growth-oriented yet disciplined. Insurer strategies were focused on underwriting and pricing for profitability and program stability. As we approach the mid-point of the decade, the property & casualty insurance industry continues to see significant transformation led by technological advancements, fluctuating consumer preferences, and evolving regulatory landscapes.
Property & Casualty Insurance is expected to leverage digital technologies to enhance customer experience. This will be in the form of interactive digital ecosystems, building unique customer intelligence, and incorporating products and services to meet the demands of a digital world. Insurers plan to adopt technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and the Internet of Things (IoT) to enhance customer service and streamline processes.
Climate Change and Property and Casualty Insurers
The increase in weather-related losses and inflation-impacted costs to revive the damaged assets continue to weigh on homeowner insurers’ profitability. As we all know, this is a segment that was already under stress due to years of persistent high loss ratios. Deloitte reported that, in 2022, ~75% of the property and casualty sector’s insured losses, or US$74 billion, were associated with the US homeowner segment.
With the severity and frequency of losses due to natural catastrophes continuing to increase at an estimated average annual growth rate of 5% – 7%, experts believe that US homeowners might see up to US$118 billion in losses by 2030 end as a result of weather events. In this situation, what should be an approach for Property and Casualty Insurers?
Insurers, in alliance with government agencies and policyholders, should invest ~US$3.35 billion in residential dwelling resiliency measures. It is being said that two-thirds of the US homes which are not built as per the codes can be made in such a way that they can steer through weather-related claims losses.
Deloitte also stated that such actions might help the property and casualty insurers save ~US$37 billion by 2030 end.
The rise in insurance rates is the most preferred way for property insurers to offset higher costs of catastrophic events. Property and Casualty Insurers shore up their premiums on homeowners so that they can make up for the rising losses. This can mean hefty profits for the leading property and casualty insurers.
S&P Global stated that, throughout the US, most of the property and casualty insurers have increased their rates for homeowners’ coverage by approximately double digits over the last year. As per NOAA, the US saw ~28 weather and climate disasters last year, outpacing the previous high of ~22 disasters in 2020. The atmospheric and oceanic conditions can result in an extremely active hurricane season. NOAA also stated that the hurricane season kicked off to a violent start with Hurricane Beryl. This is the earliest category-5 Atlantic hurricane on record.
Higher Costs and Weather-related Catastrophe Losses
More and more natural disasters continue to damage assets every year. The number of US catastrophic events went up by ~32% between 2019 and 2022. As a result of this, property and casualty insurers’ losses escalated from US$25 billion in 2019 to US$99 billion in 2022. This made a whopping ~80% of the global natural catastrophe losses. A recent report from Swiss RE has suggested that total insured losses worldwide due to weather-related natural catastrophes exceeded $122 billion last year.
Adding to this, Capgemini revealed an eye-shattering ~250% increase in economic losses in the previous 3 decades because of climate and extreme weather events.
Over 2020 and 2023, replacement costs for property and casualty-related losses increased by ~45%. This was seen when the overall inflation growth sat at ~15%. While some believe that climate change might be leading to disasters, housing demands are also driving the risk.
While the climate-related risk continues to persist, Americans still prefer to migrate to disaster-prone areas. Not only this, but they are also building higher-value homes in such regions. For example, over 1990 and 2020, ~44 million homes were built in regions where wildfires are quite common, like California and Colorado. As a result of such factors, there has been a deterioration in the US property and casualty industry combined ratio, from ~98.8% in 2020 to ~102.7% in 2022.
Amidst This Chaos, What Should Property and Casualty Insurers Do?
Property and casualty insurers should look for some alternative strategies such as loss prevention and mitigation if they want to maintain their viability in regions that are prone to extreme weather conditions.
The new homes, which are built with advanced construction materials, such as engineered timber, impact-resistant glass windows, and enhanced roof coverings, can sustain damage from severe weather conditions as compared to the existing homes. For example, the average annual expenses due to wind damage came out to be ~84% lower for the house which was built in 2022 to code compared to a 1990s-era home. As per Federal Emergency Management Agency, the average annual damages from climate change might fall by ~48% for homes meeting the specified criteria/codes.
As of now, ~35% of residences nationally have been constructed as per the desired standards and codes.
This means that property and casualty insurers can help the remaining ~65% of the homeowners improve their dwellings to meet the desired standards.
For example, the insurers can provide some policy premium discounts to homeowners. This will incentivize them to upgrade to hazard-resistant standards and codes. Property and Casualty Insurers might also make homeowners aware regarding the prevailing state-sponsored incentives.
An insurance agent at their desk consulting a customer about property & casualty insurance.
Our methodology
To compile the list of 10 Best Property & Casualty Insurance Stocks to Buy, we used the Finviz stock screener and extracted the stocks related to the property & casualty insurance industry. Once we had our filtered list, we ranked the stocks based on analysts’ average price target upside, as of August 14.
At Insider Monkey, we are obsessed with the stocks that hedge funds pile into. The reason is simple: our research has shown that we can outperform the market by imitating the top stock picks of the best hedge funds. Our quarterly newsletter’s strategy selects 14 small-cap and large-cap stocks every quarter and has returned 275% since May 2014, beating its benchmark by 150 percentage points (see more details here).
10 Best Property & Casualty Insurance Stocks to Buy
10) Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF)
Average Upside Potential: 8.20%
Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF) is a property and casualty insurance company that generates income via written premiums. A selected group of independent agencies actively markets the company’s business, home, and automotive insurance.
The company released its 2Q 2024 results, and things are looking optimistic for this property and casualty insurance company. Its revenues came in at US$2.5 billion, beating the analysts’ expectations by 3.9%. It also reported a statutory profit of US$1.98 per share, beating the analysts’ expectations by ~107%.
Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF)’s strength is in its consistent premium growth, which surpasses the industry average. Its earned premiums have witnessed a notable increase, up from $1,943 million in 2Q 2023 to $2,156 million in 2Q 2024. This showcases the company’s effectiveness in managing distribution channels and strong relationships with independent agencies.
Apart from a healthy property casualty combined ratio of 98.5% in 2Q 2024, it enjoys stable and growing investment income. The company saw its investment income rise from $220 million in 2Q 2023 to $242 million in 2Q 2024. Its financial prudence and asset management strategies should continue to provide overall financial stability.
Analysts at Keefe, Bruyette & Woods increased their target price on shares of Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF) from $146.00 to $150.00, giving an “Outperform” rating on 1st August. On average, 4 research analysts gave a “Hold” rating, and 5 analysts assigned a “Buy” rating on the shares of Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF).
As of the close of Q1 2024, 24 hedge funds in Insider Monkey’s database held stakes in Cincinnati Financial Corporation (NASDAQ:CINF). The total value of these stakes is $625.8 million.
9) The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG)
Average Upside Potential: 8.24%
The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG) provides a diverse range of property and casualty insurance, group benefits, and mutual fund services to the customer base of individuals and corporations.
Recently, the company saw the benefits of a harder insurance market together with improved pricing power. In 2Q 2024, the company saw its net income rise to $733 million, reflecting 35% growth from $542 million over the same period in 2023.
Property & Casualty written premiums went up by 12% in 2Q 2024, thanks to Commercial Lines and Personal Lines premium growth of 11% and 14%, respectively. Its commercial lines second-quarter combined ratio was 89.8 and the underlying combined ratio was 87.4.
The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG) relies on industry-leading products and strong pricing to maintain earnings and ROE growth. The company is optimistic about personal lines. It continues to make strong progress towards restoring target profitability in auto. The company has paid dividends over the previous 10 years. This means that it believes in improving shareholder value.
As a result of strong capital generation, the company announced a new share repurchase authorization of $3.3 billion. The number of hedge funds tracked by Insider Monkey owning stakes in The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG) stood at 26 in Q1 2024.
Piper Sandler increased its price target on the shares of The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG) from $112.00 to $125.00, giving an “Overweight” on 29th July.
ClearBridge Investments, an investment management firm, released its first-quarter 2024 investor letter. Here is what the fund said about The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG):
“Financials were the leading contributor to relative performance during the quarter, despite our being significantly underweight relative to the benchmark. Much of the gains were driven by our insurance holdings The Hartford Financial Services Group, Inc. (NYSE:HIG) and Arch Capital, which have benefited from a harder insurance market and increased pricing power. Hartford has improved its return on equity from low-double digits into the mid-teens through a strong industry pricing environment, rolling over investments at higher returns, and internal improvement efforts. The increase has come with a commensurate increase in earnings and its multiple, reflecting investor appreciation of businesses we have thought undervalued for quite some time. We believe the trajectory of these insurance companies is a strong one and that continued pricing power should help propel their stock prices higher in the face of interest rate cuts and market volatility.”
8) The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR)
Average Upside Potential: 8.85%
The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR) underwrites private and commercial auto insurance and specialty lines. It markets the policies via independent insurance agencies in the US and Canada and directly through internet and telephone.
The company released its 2Q 2024 financial results and exceeded the analysts’ expectations for adjusted earnings per share (EPS). However, the company slightly missed the revenue estimates. It saw EPS of $2.48, which was $0.45 higher as compared to the estimate of $2.03. The revenues came in at $17.21 billion, while the consensus estimate was $17.54 billion.
The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR)’s stock increased by over ~18% in just 6 months, mainly due to increased premiums. These premiums were supported by its healthy product portfolio, strong market position, and strength in Vehicle and Property businesses. During 2Q 2024, higher wages, coupled with a strong labor market, prompted customers to resume spending on auto insurance, which is the company’s core business.
Its rate of growth should accelerate significantly. While there are expectations of ~19% annualized revenue growth to 2024 end, its historical growth was 12% p.a. over the previous 5 years. Over the past couple of years, property and casualty insurers have been impacted by higher inflation. As a result, replacements and repair costs went up. Therefore, claim costs increased, which impacted the underlying profitability.
Despite elevated inflation levels, the company’s strong underwriting seems to be working again. The company posted a combined ratio (CR) of 91.9 in 2Q 2024. The company also enjoys strong pricing power. This is evident as it saw policies in force (PIF) growth of 9% during 2Q 2024, despite higher premiums.
Analysts at JPMorgan Chase & Co. upped their price objective on shares of The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR) from $210.00 to $239.00. They gave an “Overweight” rating on 11th July. At the end of Q1 2024, 85 hedge funds tracked by Insider Monkey held stakes in The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR).
Parnassus Investments, an investment management company, released first quarter 2024 investor letter and mentioned The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR). Here is what the fund said:
“The Progressive Corporation (NYSE:PGR) shares appreciated as investors reacted well to the insurer’s latest financials, including higher-than-expected-growth in net premiums. The company’s consistently profitable underwriting, scale advantages and strong execution are becoming more evident to investors as it continues to gain market shares.”